Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by eatonphil 3926 days ago
Hopefully not a completely ridiculous question, is there any chance cable technology like this could be used as public transportation in the future similar to in Pixar's Robots?
3 comments

Two quick answers:

1. Could it?

Depends what you mean by "cable technology like this". I haven't seen Robots, but this kind of constrained, multiple-degree-of-freedom movement would not be possible in an "open world" -- you have to have existing infrastructure, and for something like cables (which "operate" in tension only), that infrastructure has to surround the entire "vehicle". And cables have an effective practical length limit before you run into a number of physics barriers. Now, you could have something that operates by a cable pulling a car along a predefined route, but it would be a simple linear movement. Not only can you, we already do this: most ski lifts work this way. So do, for example, the SF cable cars.

2. Even if you could, should you?

The tl;dr here is that in the vast majority of modern cases, other technology is better. If you're going to expend a whole bunch of money on infrastructure, which is necessary for public transportation in general, why not make it something higher capacity? Lightrail, or high-speed bus, or really almost any other form of public transportation is more effective. Where the ski lift approach shines is in low-volume, low-speed transport across terrain that would be very, very difficult (read: expensive) to lay tracks or road across, like mountains. Similarly, the cable car approach shines in situations where rails offer questionable traction in adverse conditions, and a positive connection with something is hugely beneficial (like a very steep hill). There are always niche applications, but I wouldn't hold my breath for widespread use.

Come visit beautiful San Francisco! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/San_Francisco_cable_car_system

I think the wires would get in each other's way if you had pods in the same volume.

Ah of course, that was silly of me. I guess I meant suspended cable travel.
You are right! But it is now apparent that the question I had in mind is completely different from the one I actually asked. nbadg caught on to what I meant which was more along the lines of: could suspended cable transportation be a feasible mode of public transportation in cities?
Yes. The biggest benefit is very low ground footprint and highly predictable traffic flow. A few articles discuss it as a reasonable form of mass transit.

http://urbanland.uli.org/infrastructure-transit/public-trans...

http://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/commute-by-gondola-...

This is really cool. Thank you for sharing!
"Robots" is not a Pixar movie.
Ouch, my mistake. 20th Century Fox's Robots.