Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by JosephRedfern 3940 days ago
That's cool. Presumably the same "attack" could be applied to any file format that uses DEFLATE.

From a legal stand-point, I'd be wary about following through with the authors suggestion of "Upload as your profile picture to some online service, try to crash their image processing scripts" without permission. Sounds like a good way of getting into trouble.
2 comments
cnvogel 3940 days ago
Yes, but on the other hand it's a good reminder for everyone processing user provided files to sanity check or convert them to a canonical format in a sandboxes and resource limited process.
link
atom_enger 3940 days ago
What about responsibly disclosing the bug you found with steps to reproduce, the impact and the solution? As long as you only timed out the backend without entirely crashing it, I can't imagine any sane company would prosecute you for trying to improve their service with this level of detail.
link
JosephRedfern 3940 days ago
How do you know that you're only going to time out the backend without entirely crashing it, without actually attempting it? It's a kinda Schrödinger's cat scenario.

It's all good and well saying that you had good intentions, but if you can't prove it, and they didn't invite you to test it (via a responsible disclosure policy), then I would steer clear.

While I wouldn't personally attempt to prosecute anyone for responsibly disclosing a bug to me, it doesn't meant to say that BigCorp™ wouldn't.

link