[unabst]

> 'oh well, science is full of assumptions therefore science is invalid.'

No, they are saying "science is based on assumption, but in this case 'many scientists' were making the wrong assumptions." The title should have said "scientists find errors in p-values as premises." Assumptions are avoided, not depended upon. Bad assumptions would certainly lead to irreplicable experiments also.

The distinction you make between science and its experiments is not a common distinction. If science = experiments, then you totally agree that this kind of science is bad science. Which was precisely my point.