Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by bgentry 3961 days ago
The Golang Gopher is a design of Renee French, and the lack of attribution here is disappointing. Wouldn't these derivative works also be covered by her copyright?

https://blog.golang.org/gopher
2 comments
jerf 3961 days ago
The original Gopher is licensed under the Creative Commons 3 Attribution license: https://golang.org/doc/gopher/README

While technically you could license your own stuff under the WTFPL, these gopher images are still CC BY 3.0 underneath that.

link
arihant 3961 days ago
I think in CC BY 3.0, as long as proper attribution is given, license of derivative works can be changed.

Licensor cannot revoke adaptation rights, as long as attribution is given, even for commercial use.

So the use of WTFPL is fine here, but the lack of attribution renders CC BY 3.0 non-applicable, and hence makes this repo a copyright infringement.

link
jerf 3961 days ago
That's pretty much what I was trying to say... you can decline to add more license to your own work, and decline to ask for your own attribution, but you can't erase the underlying license and WTFPL the whole thing, as the only license.
link
magnusgraviti 3961 days ago
We have already added licensing. Now it must be ok.
link
arihant 3960 days ago
Good that you took action. But it is still not compliant. You must link to original work by Renee. You need include link to her blog, where she posted the design.

See here: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/

> If supplied, you must provide the name of the creator and attribution parties, a copyright notice, a license notice, a disclaimer notice, and a link to the material.

For reference, here is how official Golang README puts it:

> The Go gopher was designed by Renee French. (http://reneefrench.blogspot.com/)

link
sbt 3961 days ago
The lack of attribution here is refreshing. I am sick of living in a world where all ideas have to be meticulously accounted for.
link
arihant 3961 days ago
It is also against the spirit of CC, and also against CC BY 3.0, which Gopher is licensed under.

If you don't like attributing, do not use things licensed under CC. It's that simple.

link
coldtea 3961 days ago
What if you are also against adhering to license terms?
link
arihant 3960 days ago
One is free to do what one likes, but there are consequences.
link