Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by namos 3956 days ago
Well, kinda. A RIPA s.49 notice can be defeated with s.53 defenses.

Some people have failed to pass the test of "reasonable doubt" for s.53 (3) / (4) defenses e.g. ( http://www.alphr.com/news/361693/teenager-jailed-for-refusin... ) but in other cases they have succeeded (e.g. Lauri Love had his hdd's taken and the NCA couldn't decrypt them but had to release him on bail; http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-suffolk-31544346 and subsequently returned some of the storage (before arresting him again))

There are also people out there working to help the reasonable doubt argument; https://brasshorncommunications.uk/projects/s53/

1 comments

NB: Lauri is now facing three parallel extradition request to the USA as an indirect consequence of failure to comply with a court order to facilitate decryption.

This is not ideal, but will probably fail, hopefully with some precedent set.

[http://theconversation.com/hactivists-arent-terrorists-but-u...]