Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by mrottenkolber 3955 days ago
So I upload a DJ mix and it gets rejected because of "Copyright blah blah". Then I fill out the form and tell them "Guys, it's a DJ mix, not the song you claim it to be". I never received a response. So I guess SoundCloud is no longer for me.
3 comments
deng 3955 days ago
If you are using copyrighted music in your mix for more than a few seconds, I'm afraid SoundCloud has no other choice.
link
kevin_thibedeau 3955 days ago
That argument didn't work for Vanilla Ice. Why would you think your samples are immune?
link
globuous 3955 days ago
What are the laws on using copyrighted material in mixes do you know ? I know Sound of Monte Carlo's soundcloud (they uplaod monthly mixes or w/e) is about to be taken down, they do use copyrighted material in their mixes though.
link
DrJokepu 3955 days ago
In the US, if you use someone else's work or recording in your work, it's derivative work and unless the original work was in the public domain or your usage constitutes "fair use" (e.g. parody), you need to get their permission.

In the UK, where Soundcloud is based, it's very similar, except the equivalent of "fair use" is called "fair dealing" and it's much more restrictive in scope.

link
chefkoch 3955 days ago
I thought soundcloud is based in Berlin?
link
DrJokepu 3955 days ago
They're registered in the United Kingdom (England and Wales): https://soundcloud.com/imprint
link
mrottenkolber 3955 days ago
No idea about the legal situation. And to be frank I don't care. I have no economic incentive for my hobby. I consider it an art and a means of expression along the lines of singing and dancing. For all I care I am doing commercial musicians a favor for promoting their work, but really that's just an unintended side effect. SoundCloud was profiting of me giving away free content. Its people like me that enabled its business in the first place. So in the end its their loss, and they will fail because of the laws. I personally don't mourn the loss of SoundCloud as a viable publishing platform. I have many choices and it was never my primary platform to begin with (which is an independent pirate radio).

My point is that the laws don't stop the people doing the "infringing". We don't care. Its the businesses that could profit from the human need for creativity that are hurt by the absurd situation.

link
DrJokepu 3955 days ago
Surely, infringers of the GPL could cite the same argument?
link
mrottenkolber 3955 days ago
I am sure RMS is with me on this one.
link