Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by joshuapants 3966 days ago
I say the following as a Linux enthusiast: Ubuntu is absolutely not "ready for the prime time," as you put it.

It's not ready for home users, it's not ready for most businesses, it's not ready for anyone except a small number of users.

3 comments

Yep. I want to love it (I want to love it so much). I just can't.

Audio still doesn't work on my installation. It can work if I kill Flash or pulseaudio---sometimes---or if I restart my browser or entire machine---sometimes. But it's an atrocious state of affairs to expect end-users to debug basic functionality like that, and they end up having to because there isn't a "Geek Squad" local-service ecosystem to take a malfunctioning Linux machine to (with your own customized distro install) where they can just "make it work."

It's not just a software problem---it's an ecosystem problem. Both in terms of the service / support sector and in terms of the software creation sector (the fact that there isn't just one answer to "How do I do audio on Linux" is absolutely maddening to someone used to writing software on a Mac / Win monoculture [http://braid-game.com/news/2008/08/misc-linux-questions/]).

Why?
In comparison to OSX and Windows running on the same hardware, Ubuntu is worse in every meaningful way. Power management is terrible, window management is terrible, the Ubuntu software center is slow as hell and has no selection (amount of useful software is a huge concern, actually). It lacks polish in general, things that people have come to take for granted in their OSs are missing or badly implemented.

I'm sure the argument will come that most home users only need a web browser, so the software selection isn't a problem, but at that point you might as well just use Chrome OS and get something that actually works.

Not for gaming (yet! vulcan will change that), but for everything else I think it's absolutely ready. It does internet perfectly through Firefox, and libre office for document things, plays all file types through VLC, and it's free and can run securely right off a USB stick. What else do I need a computer for? Apps? I have my phone for that.

Once it gets increased adoption more niche and paid for software will naturally migrate.

I say this as a Linux hating Windows lover who lasted 3 hours before reverting Win 10 back to 8.1 on my gaming machine and changing my wifi password, and I plan to never go to Win 10 or any Windows products again.

I hear this for last 15 years, and few things changed. Showstoppers - 100% compatibility with Office will probably never happen, which is deal breaker for most business customers actually paying for licences. second issue is device drivers. users don't care who-what is responsible, they just want to see their strange printer working with scans. Again, in many cases not there