Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by scrollaway 3971 days ago
No, the blocker is setting up mailing lists with a forum-like interface (cf. discourse), but integrated to github (uses the github account) and without actually having to do the setup. Also, without polluting issues.
2 comments
e12e 3971 days ago
Actually opening issues via email would be nice to. Trac isn't perfect, but I remember email2trac[1] quite fondly. Combined with email notifications on change, it made it easy to forward bug/error-reports to a trac instance, and automatically create an issue. Or just let support@ go straight to trac.

I still think having an email interface (as in: in addition to a REST API) is very useful. Having a web interface as well isn't bad either.

[1] https://oss.trac.surfsara.nl/email2trac

link
dvanduzer 3971 days ago
Good project-specific labels to GH issues solves the "polluting" problem. The label/tag system is nicely flexible.

It sounds like what you really want is nested threads and top quoting and/or interstitial quote/response features?

(Arguably what you really need is commonly called a conference.)

link