Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
Organic Maps Turns 4: The Privacy-Focused Alternative to Google Maps (organicmaps.app)
7 points by rtsisyk 540 days ago
3 comments

What have we achieved so far as we approach Christmas 2024:

- ~3M¹ users from all countries of the world

- ~15k ratings and reviews on AppStore and Google Play

- 4.8/4.6 average rating on AppStore/Google Play

- 10k+ stars on GitHub

- 10k (almost) issues + PRs on GitHub

- 1k (almost) forks on GitHub

- 7k+ git commits

- ~100 awesome contributors who made 5+ commits

- $0 spend on marketing - pure Organic growth

(fixed formatting)

Interesting, I will try !

What would you say are the fundamental differences between Organic Maps and OsmAnd?

Pros of Organic Maps compared to OsmAnd -

* Rendering and routing are faster (especially noticeable on older devices)

* Renders 3D buildings

* Far smpler UI, so it's hard for tech-illiterate users to get stuck

* Changes made with the Organic Maps editor become visible in your Organic Maps immediately. In OsmAnd, your edits vanish upon upload, and only appear once there is a map update - this can be as early as in one hour (using OsmAnd Live), or as late as one month.

* Organic Maps is less buggy.

Cons of Organic Maps compared to OsmAnd -

* OsmAnd has far more features, like bus or share taxi routing, aerial imagery, 3D relief, analysis of GPS tracks, radius ruler, etc

* OsmAnd can render a lot more data like street surface, smoothness, access restrictions, lighting, features with FIXME tags, OSM notes, etc.

* Organic Maps only updates data once a month. OsmAnd updates data monthly too, but also has the OsmAnd Live feature to update data every hour.

* OsmAnd's editor supports adding arbitrary keys, whereas Organic Maps' does not.

Congratulations !

If you are a french speaker and looking for a Web equivalent, check out https://cartes.app.

Source code at github.com/cartesapp

It's not clear to me in the article: which version of MAPS.ME was forked? The latest version 1 from end of 2020?

Also, I didn't know MAPS.ME had been open source since 2015!

https://github.com/mapsme/omim/ was forked in December 2020, with all new changes up to the last commit of Apr 28, 2021 merged into https://github.com/organicmaps/organicmaps/ later. MAPS.ME is alive, but they publish the source code anymore since that.