Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
The dark side of rapeseed oil (2018) (smartholistics.co.uk)
10 points by aarobot 1645 days ago
9 comments

There are no citations for these claims in the article. While I'm inclined to avoid canola oil because there are better alternatives that are less contentious, I'm also not going to just accept the author's claims without sources.
A quick web search suggests that it's nothing to be concerned about.

https://efsa.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.2903/j.efsa...

It would seem that way, I would still prefer olive oil given the choice.
I am curious if the "Canola" name was invented because "Rape" is hard to market in English-speaking countries.
This seems to be woo. Here's the Wikipedia entry on erucic acid: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erucic_acid#Health_effects.

Key takeaway: "However, more recent research has cast doubt on the relevance of rat studies to the human health of erucic acid. Rats are unusual in their inability to process erucic acid, and the symptoms in rats caused by a diet with high levels of erucic acid has not been observed in pigs, primates, or any other animals."

In any case, mustard oil has been the primary cooking oil in India since time immemorial, so if high-erucic acid cooking oils were a problem, we'd absolutely know about it by now.

Lard and tallow have been cooking fats for centuries, and we've only had medical reports of heart conditions since plant oils became an industry.
How does uncited trash like this make it the front page?
I've learned to stay away from canola oil - first, I don't find it very neutral and often can tell when a place uses canola oil. Second, there seems to be a correlation between a restaurant using canola oil and me have gastro issues - not always, so I'm wondering if it is only some brands that restaurants uses that is cheaper, or maybe they reuse it too much. I had read about someone else having issues and they whenever they did, they would call the restaurant and find out what oil they used, so I started to do the same. While not all restaurants that use canola oil cause problems, whenever I have had an issue, the restaurant always were using canola oil. Very anecdotal, obviously.

I stick to peanut, soybean, or mostly extra light olive oil (or EVO for non-cooking needs).

Have you tried avocado oil?
>Added to this, much of the rape now grown worldwide is GMO – genetically modified – although not currently here in the UK, which raises many other issues.

I've always wondered what are those "issues" of genetically modified crops? If anything I would love for us to create a plant that is very low in the arctic acid they say it's bad.

The only valid argument I've heard against GMOs is that they could decrease species diversity in some crops (like corn, which in Mexico we have hundreds of varieties, and the introduction of GMO corn could out compete those local varieties)

Unnecessary and overpriced patents is a start.
This article can't even spell erucic acid right, no citations for any of its claims...
There are no citations, this is just wild speculation.
Hmm - not sure I want un-sourced advice from an anti-vaxxer on what is safe to consume.