Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
Florida Community Furious at Release of 500M Gene-Hacked Mosquitoes (futurism.com)
7 points by fjsofkjdsfkos 1882 days ago
3 comments

I'm nervous about this because it's not like living lifeforms don't have a track of adapting and overcoming evolutionary hurdles. I really hope it works as expected and they have contingency plans ready, because I'm sure they're not staying there if experiment fails.
this worries me too:

"the EPA never asked Oxitec to conduct any caged trials — experiments that would show how well the mosquitoes perform in a controlled environment — before allowing the company to go ahead and send its insects out into the world."

that seems a bit nuts

“I find it criminal that we are being subjected to this terrorism by our own Florida Keys Mosquito Control Board.”

“We have everything to risk, nothing to gain, and it’s all for Oxitec’s bottom line,”

I'm so sick of hyperbole.

Having lived in Florida, I welcome this.

TL;DR

> Donaldson was in a hurry, so she says she signed their clipboard and watched as they hung a small, black mosquito capture cup from a tree in her yard.

> “I don’t even know what I signed. I just signed my name,” she said. “I was like ‘Oh, mosquito control, yeah whatever.'”

> Oxitec says the mosquitoes, all males — which don’t bite humans — will then breed with wild females, which do bite. But they’ll pass on the OX5034 gene, a hereditary payload that prevents any female offspring from reaching adulthood. The theory is that the more the gene-hacked mosquitoes and their descendants reproduce, the fewer biting female mosquitoes there will be in the area.

> This real-world experiment, which is scheduled to begin imminently, will target the mosquito species Aedes aegypti. These bugs only make up two to four percent of the mosquito population in the Florida Keys, but they’re associated with nearly all cases of mosquito-borne illnesses. Oxitec says the trial could help stop the spread of insect-borne diseases that affect humans, like dengue and Zika, by preventing the bugs that carry them from surviving.

> The mosquitoes released [...] carry two copies of the gene, but because they’re mating with females in the wild, their offspring only get one. That means fewer and fewer will carry the OX5034 trait until it gets filtered out of the wild altogether.

Unless what I'm reading are outright lies, I would welcome this if I lived in the area.

It's an experiment on the real World with no undo button. We better be damn sure nothing bad will happen. Are they liable for dammages if something goes wrong? Unintended consequences, unkown unknowns...