Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
Show HN: Draw and extract tables from PDF reliably (getbluetail.com)
3 points by kjhitcher 2275 days ago
1 comments
saradhi 2275 days ago
Reliably* - coming with limitations

  1. Text pdfs only 

  2. Template is needed
From what I've spoken with 50-60 paid customers for a service I maintain, the most common concerns I listen are

  1. No, We get scan pdfs as well 

  2. No, We deal with lot of customers, cannot template all
link
kjhitcher 2275 days ago
Yes, agreed that this is indeed a difficult tradeoff.

Just curious, does extracttable.com provide offline mode? It seems that quite a few people can't submit their documents to 3rd party server

link
saradhi 2275 days ago
We are far away from offline mode. May be 2-3 years later thing, if we survive till that time.

Btw, did you check OpenCV morph line detection? It will help to auto detect the evident cell/row boundaries - thus reducing human effort

link
kjhitcher 2275 days ago
I did a bit, but there are tables that simply don't have any lines. Given that human beings are just so much better at detecting tables than AI, I figured maybe the solution is to help people quickly draw the table they see, rather than tweaking algorithm -- hence this new product.
link