IMHO - On the signup popup form. If you want to close it without entering an email address you have to click a link that says - "No thanks, I hate saving money" - it seems to go against the friendliness of the rest of the branding.
I agree. I suck at marketing, so had someone come up with that, but I actually hate it myself, so will try to think of something else. I genuinely want to build something useful that will bring people to the site because it helps them rather that annoy them!
IMHO forcing visitors to be "polite" to a site is just as sneaky as using "I hate saving money". It's all meant to make a visitor feel guilty about clicking it. Just add a simple old close button and don't play marketing mind-games with your users, please.
I agree with your intuition. The likelihood that the person actually hates saving money is approximately zero. What they are actually saying is that you haven't earned their trust enough yet to cough up their email address. So when you force the question with a timed modal, they have three options: sending their email address to a site they don't trust, clicking a link that's simply a lie or just closing the tab and never coming back. Why on earth would they pick anything but the last option?
After I commented I read through some of the other replies and realize at this point it probably feels like folks are piling on this one relatively small issue. Sorry for that, but I do think it's a good sign that you're asking for (and getting haha) real feedback.
Thanks, I do try to create something useful, but I will make it less intrusive and spell out from A - Z what the purpose of the site is, and what it is not, so that I hopefully will not start world war 3
As someone who runs a SaaS business, lifetime subscriptions seem like the worst idea ever. I can't imagine it gets you that many more people who wouldn't buy otherwise, vs the incredible risk you take that you've correctly predicted the cost of providing your service forever.
Yes, there surely are many pitfalls, both for customers and companies. I think it is important for the company not to overpromise in cases like this. But I guess one of the main reasons companies do lifetime deals, is to get initial traction, and fastet build a very dedicated group of beta users. If they handle that correctly, it can be a big asset, and cheaper than many other forms of startup marketing.
This is actually the reason why I do not buy any lifetime membership. Because of the risks involved it seems to me that buying lifetime memberships run the risk for the customer of overspending when the service closes shop. Or in some way getting screwed.
An obviously bad monetization strategy is more of a warning sign than no monetization strategy at all.
This is a pretty useful list. In some cases I actively avoid businesses with this model as I do not believe the business model is sustainable. But it really depends. If i'm buying FTP software (e.g. transmit) then fine. But if i'm buying a VPN, no chance.
I would suggest moving the source column on the table. At first I found it hard to read as the primary data I'm looking for is the service, not the source.
Also, remove your obnoxious newsletter popup, especially with the "No thanks, i hate to save money" dismiss...
That "No Thanks, I hate to save money" is a classic dark pattern designed to manipulate people. There's tons of articles about how damaging they are to users perceptions of the interactions (Example https://www.nngroup.com/articles/shaming-users/ ). I honestly closed the browser and didn't give the content any look due to it, as if you're going to try to shame me into giving you my email address, you're not going to play fair with anything else.
Thank you for your opinion. I agree, and will rephrase it later today. I have tried to be very forthcoming about what the site is about, sticking my affiliate link disclaimer on top of every page, so I sincerely do not want to have a popup that makes people vomit!
I used to believe the same, how can someone offer a VPN service with a lifetime deal? How can they predict my bandwidth usage? Maybe there will be a fine print wrt usage.
Long story short I decided to buy a service called Windscribe 2 years ago anyway after reading some reddit replies (it's a lifetime deal) and so far my experience has been amazing. It's actually better than some monthly paid services I've used and the only service that allows me to watch Netflix US. So exceptions are there though it's only been 2 years using them.. so fingers crossed!
Yes, I agree the popup was annoying. I used a template I found, and understand it was annoying, stupid, disrespectful etc. I have now removed it. It is clearly stated on top of every page that there are affiliate links on the site. I spend 20+ hours weekly finding deals and updating the deal list. If it turns out the world hates this, I can stop doing it, close the site down, and do something else with my time. It seemed however some people found it useful, so I thought why not see if people found it useful.
I'd also be interested in why some of your external scripts are (very badly and slowly) trying to fingerprint the browser and do persistent tracking. Your aiva thing is triggering "site is attempting to load adobe flash" notice bars.
It also tries to spin up the GPU, ruining battery life.
I am curious if you've actually tried all of these, or if you're just going with whatever offers affiliate money, because a decent number are either pretty much ad-packed open source projects being sold with a windows GUI/the type of stuff you see on clickbank with a landing page that looks like spam/actual garbage/run by criminals.
I am not a programmer, so I tried to find a tool for email signups, and Aiva looked nice at the time. Guessing from your reply, it is bad in some way, so I have turned it off. I do not need it. As for the rest of your question, I have made it clearer in the text on the deal dashboard. I borrowed your text, hope you don't mind.
My main idea is to find every single deal online that is labeled lifetime deal, and share it in a simple, searchable, sortable overview list. The list will contain my affiliate links, so I can hopefully some day earn more money from the site than I spend. If you have other suggestions to how to label things so people do not get fooled, let me know. If you think the best thing is to delete the site from existance, then I will actually think about doing so. I had a hope it was possible to show a list of links online, be they affiliate links, in some way so that it could still be useful. But maybe it is not.
Personally, my belief is that a completely unvetted, uncurated list of links is not very useful. Maybe others may differ.
It would be more work but I would much rather look at a list of curated services that are also affiliate links that tell me why they are good and maybe a pros/cons/alternative-to-x table. If I am looking for a completely uncurated list I could go to stacksocial and search for the word lifetime. A short 1-2 sentences would at least tide me over as to what the product does.
It is less about the fooled, but more that quite a lot of that list is garbage software, the kind you see included in adware installers as trials - like the PDF converters, the lying VPN providers that won't actually last a lifetime, I'm trying to find a list of deals that specifically removes these.
I guess it comes down to a difference it what people look for. When I set about creating this site, it was because I like getting these deals and try out new software myself, but I found myself missing some of the best deals. So I set up alerts, signed up for lots of fb groups, and checked lots of sites, but it took a lot of time, and suddenly I hade made myself a dashboard. As it is right now, the site does what I personally like, it shows a list of ongoing lifetime deals from any source I can find, and one can get the same info in email alerts or rss subscribtion. Personally I hate comparison tables, because how can I know the person who made them has tested all tools compared and know them well enough to make a fair comparison. So I actually thought it more fair to just post the links. But these comments have given me some food for thought, so I think I need to make things clearer in writing on each page.
Thanks for the great suggestions, I will try to implement some improvements this week. If nobody cares about the first column, I can at least move it to the far right As for the business model, I have gotten some great tools from startups that are trying to get off the ground, but of course there are also some tools that never seem to get anywhere after initial rounds. It's a good idea to ask the founders for roadmaps, company details etc.
I remember when Quip were on Appsumo and I went for it but couldn’t understand why they were doing lifetime deals. Then several months later Salesforce came along with a $300m acquisition and it all made sense - user base.
That said I will generally avoid ‘award winning’ software I’ve never heard of (after buying one Appsumo product I realised the software was a dud) and I also avoid any critical services (lifetime 10Tb cloud backup for $5... no way)