Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
How Smart Is Your State? US States Ranked by Patents per Million People (sharcmedia.com)
9 points by graemeklass 6668 days ago
6 comments
wastedbrains 6668 days ago
If you don't really agree with software patents this measure doesn't work well...
link
gojomo 6668 days ago
I doubt software patents contribute much to the totals, or would change the rankings if left out. Same for business method patents.

And you might disagree with patents entirely but still see them as correlated with a certain type of intelligent opportunism.

Pretty sure Idaho owes its ranking to a few key corporate research groups in patent-heavy fields -- HP, Micron, ?

link
edw519 6668 days ago
I think "cashiers who can make change without a cash register" would be a better measure.
link
graywh 6668 days ago
A lot of things would be a better measure.
link
graemeklass 6667 days ago
For those that want to experiment with the KML file you can download it at http://www.sharcmedia.com/kml/PatentsPerMillion2.kml

Regarding a finer grained heat map it would be cool, but I couldn't find any finer grained data (eg. by US Postcode) on the USPTO site.

link
scw 6668 days ago
It'd be much better if they de-aggregated this information over the surface to create a true 'heat map'. If they did this, you'd probably see true hotspots of patent innovation which I'll bet correspond nicely to startup hubs.
link
pg 6668 days ago
This would be a lot better if the colors varied continuously.
link
graywh 6668 days ago
Yes, the graphic could use some help from http://www.colorbrewer.org/.
link
chaostheory 6667 days ago
nice, a patent troll ranking for the US
link