Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
The Closed Mind of Richard Dawkins (newrepublic.com)
6 points by mdariani 3822 days ago
2 comments

Hm. I find no discussion of this essay at all in that thread? Just some tangential digressions.
Have I got it wrong? I'll check - sorry - stand by ...

(pause)

Right. So the link I've given is to an earlier submission of exactly this article, and the thread there has 52 comments in it. There is some discussion of this article in that thread, but as you say, it's mostly digressions.

I wonder if that's true of many HN threads.

So you're right - there is a discussion, but although it's in reply to this article, it's not of this article.

I'll leave my comment there.

tl;dr: essayist personally attacks Richard Dawkins while playing apologist for religious folks.